Variation in Eurostat and national statistics of accidents in agriculture
Laen...
Kuupäev
2019
Kättesaadav alates
Autorid
Merisalu, Eda
Leppälä, J.
Jakob, M.
Rautiainen, R.H.
Ajakirja pealkiri
Ajakirja ISSN
Köite pealkiri
Kirjastaja
Abstrakt
Agriculture is known as a hazardous industry worldwide, although there are great
challenges in enumerating the size of the workforce and numbers of accidents at work. The aim
of the study was to characterize variation in agricultural accident statistics in European countries
and opportunities to improve collection and reporting of accident data in agriculture on the
national and European levels. This study explored the incidence of fatal (FA) and non-fatal work
accidents (NFA) in agriculture (excluding forestry and fishing) in selected European countries,
using Eurostat and national sources in 2013. Eurostat reported highest NFA rates (per 100,000
workers) in Finland (5331) and lowest in Greece (5). The highest FA rate was reported in Malta
(51), while zero fatalities were reported in Estonia, Greece, Luxembourg, Slovenia, Sweden and
Iceland. Eurostat and national statistics differed in many cases. Some variations were observed
in European and national statistics. Germany reported 89 fatalities (rate 2.3/100,000) in Eurostat
and 160 (rate 16.3/100,000) in national sources. Poland, with a similar land area and five times
more farms and workers as Germany, reported only 4 fatalities in agriculture in Eurostat. The
Estonian Labour Inspectorate (2013) registered 785 NFAs per 100,000 agricultural workers,
while the rate in Eurostat was more than twice as high (1914/100,000). Finland and Sweden with
similar agricultural structures had a ten-fold difference in NFA rates in Eurostat; Finland 5,331
and Sweden 554 per 100,000 workers. These examples illustrate the large variation in agricultural
accident statistics due to: a) farm structure, b) use of reference populations, c) under-reporting,
d) different inclusion/exclusion criteria and e) interpretation by users. Some inconsistencies are
structural due to lacking social insurance schemes for farmers, family labour and undocumented
workers. Some inconsistencies could be addressed by better implementation of ESAW
harmonizing rules. Alternative methods, such as standardized surveys, could be considered to
augment Eurostat statistics.
Kirjeldus
Article
Märksõnad
agriculture, farm, worker, accident, injury, quality, statistics, articles